The U.S. Dairy Exporter Blog: Market Analysis, Research & News
-
Parsing the Export Pricing Puzzle
By Tom Suber April 12, 2010- Tweet
On paper, based on published cheese, butter and powder prices, U.S. dairy suppliers currently have a huge edge over European Union (EU) and Oceania exporters. The casual observer may wonder why then U.S. overseas sales aren’t quickly ramping back up. In reality, the apparent pricing advantage isn’t always quite what it seems.
Comparing international dairy cost competitiveness, unfortunately, is not as easy as simply subtracting the Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME) block cheddar price from the Dairy Market News survey price of cheddar from Oceania suppliers. Until you factor in all the variables—everything from demand to the timing of the sale to preferential tariff rates—you can’t get an accurate reading on the price differential.
Some of those variables can be quantified to a certain extent. For example, Oceania and EU quotations are FOB port; U.S. prices are ex-plant and do not include the costs and fees needed to get the product to port. In addition, suppliers need to factor in higher U.S. freight fees to markets like China, Japan, South Korea and Southeast Asia, where Oceania holds a geographic advantage, and the Middle East where Europe benefits from its proximity.
Depending on the product, oil prices, plant location and destination, logistics and shipping alone can add anywhere from 10 to 20 cents per lb. to U.S. published prices.
That’s a pretty straightforward calculation. The comparison grows increasingly complex as you factor in everything from product specs to intangibles such as market presence. In fact, the nature of the variables makes it virtually impossible to generate an apples-to-apples comparison between U.S. and EU, Australian or New Zealand butter, powder and, in particular, cheese.
Published cheese prices are spot prices, while Oceania suppliers operate with 3-6 month contracts for their bigger customers. Contract prices theoretically can be higher or lower than spot prices, but in any case can lock out U.S. business for significant portions of the year no matter the CME block cheddar price. When it’s time to renegotiate the contract, assuming the inventory is there, the Australian or Kiwi supplier can reduce its prices to ensure that it holds the customer.
Secondly, the CME and published Oceania prices in essence refer to different products. Since the vast majority of internationally traded bulk cheese is converted to processed cheese, overseas buyers expect white cheddar at standard Oceania moisture content (35-36 percent), rather than CME-spec yellow cheddar at 36.5-39 percent moisture.
Those differences are recognized in dollars, as Oceania suppliers discount off published prices for product used for processing (the primary use for U.S. block cheddar) to compensate for the discrepancy in solids content.
The spec differences go well beyond block cheddar. The United States simply does not routinely manufacture products preferred by the international market, and that always plays out in pricing.
U.S. suppliers rarely achieve top-end prices for nonfat dry milk/skim milk powder (NDM/SMP) because they produce a low-heat product. A far greater number of global buyers demand medium heat.
Many world buyers also utilize NDM/SMP for recombining, and therefore demand low spore content, something U.S. manufacturers as a rule don’t provide, or at least test sufficiently to guarantee.
Butter differences are also well known. We make 80 percent, salted butter. The EU and Oceania make 82 percent unsalted.
U.S. suppliers' resistance to manufacture to global demand as well as our reputation as “opportunistic” sellers often make us the supplier of last resort, earning us, as one trader puts it, “Johnny-come-lately pricing.”
Under such a scenario, just because the domestic cheese or powder price is attractive one day—or even one quarter—doesn’t mean people are going to line up immediately to buy or that we are necessarily going to generate huge amounts of overseas business.
U.S. suppliers can help their own cause though by demonstrating that they want to be in the market and not just play the market. We have developed the image as the supplier of last resort, which can generate business when conditions are favorable but not sustainable business. And, in practice, we have often become the last-in and first-out of market cycles.
The United States still has not adopted the global mindset required to evolve the business into a consistent international player. U.S. suppliers on the whole need to get out in front of overseas buyers more consistently, demonstrate better customer service and create products that better meet global buyer needs. That would minimize the effect of the variables in the pricing equation, put us on a more equal footing with our competitors and more regularly result in improved volumes and less volatility.
(This article first appeared in Cheese Market News in April 2010.)
The U.S. Dairy Export Council represents dairy farmers, proprietary processors, cooperatives, ingredient suppliers and export traders. Its mission is to enhance U.S. competitiveness and increase global sales of U.S. dairy ingredients and products.
10 Most Recent Posts
Most Popular Posts in Past Year
Index of Posts by Topic
- #GotDairyJobs (4)
- About USDEC (40)
- Africa (5)
- Australia (4)
- Blog (8)
- Brazil (4)
- Canada (17)
- Central America (1)
- Cheese (46)
- China (52)
- Common food names (4)
- Company News (7)
- Crisis Management (3)
- Cuba (2)
- Dairy (5)
- Dairy checkoff (6)
- Dairy Resources (1)
- Dairy Trends (4)
- Documentation (3)
- EU (19)
- Exports (16)
- Farming (21)
- Food Aid (8)
- Food Safety (8)
- Foodservice (3)
- Free trade agreements (31)
- Geographical Indications (GIs) (8)
- Global Marketing (86)
- Got Jobs? (7)
- Indonesia (1)
- Innovation (16)
- Japan (17)
- Market Access (23)
- Market Conditions (174)
- Member Services (15)
- Mexico (35)
- Middle East (8)
- Middle East & North Africa (3)
- Middle East/North Africa (8)
- Milk (1)
- Milk Protein Concentrate (MPC) (2)
- New Zealand (10)
- Next5% (20)
- Nonfat Dry Milk/Skim Milk Powder (8)
- Nutrition (16)
- Product Innovation (3)
- Protein (3)
- Regulations (5)
- Research & Data (228)
- Russia (3)
- Singapore (7)
- South America (6)
- South Korea (8)
- Southeast Asia (20)
- Sustainability (9)
- Technology (2)
- ThinkUSADairy (3)
- TPP (13)
- Traceability (8)
- Trade Barriers (5)
- Trade Data (3)
- Trade Policy (57)
- TTIP (5)
- UHT Milk (7)
- Vietnam (4)
- Whey (5)
- Whey Ingredients (1)
- Whey products (10)
- Whole Milk Powder (WMP) (3)
- World Dairy Expo (1)
- Yogurt (1)
Index of Posts by Date, Author
- March 2015 (12)
- September 2015 (12)
- March 2014 (11)
- April 2015 (11)
- December 2015 (11)
- February 2015 (10)
- October 2015 (10)
- October 2014 (9)
- June 2015 (9)
- July 2015 (9)
- November 2015 (9)
- March 2016 (9)
- October 2019 (9)
- September 2013 (8)
- May 2015 (8)
- August 2015 (8)
- January 2016 (8)
- February 2016 (8)
- March 2017 (8)
- December 2018 (8)
- May 2019 (8)
- June 2014 (7)
- November 2016 (7)
- May 2017 (7)
- May 2018 (7)
- July 2016 (6)
- August 2018 (6)
- October 2018 (6)
- November 2018 (6)
- February 2019 (6)
- June 2019 (6)
- August 2019 (6)
- February 2014 (5)
- June 2016 (5)
- August 2016 (5)
- September 2016 (5)
- December 2016 (5)
- February 2017 (5)
- July 2017 (5)
- October 2017 (5)
- January 2018 (5)
- April 2018 (5)
- June 2018 (5)
- July 2018 (5)
- September 2018 (5)
- January 2019 (5)
- March 2019 (5)
- April 2019 (5)
- July 2019 (5)
- September 2019 (5)
- November 2019 (5)
- May 2013 (4)
- September 2014 (4)
- April 2016 (4)
- May 2016 (4)
- October 2016 (4)
- January 2017 (4)
- April 2017 (4)
- June 2017 (4)
- August 2017 (4)
- September 2017 (4)
- December 2017 (4)
- February 2018 (4)
- December 2019 (4)
- November 2017 (3)
- March 2018 (3)
- March 2011 (2)
- June 2011 (2)
- September 2011 (2)
- March 2012 (2)
- June 2012 (2)
- July 2012 (2)
- March 2013 (2)
- July 2013 (2)
- January 2010 (1)
- February 2010 (1)
- March 2010 (1)
- April 2010 (1)
- May 2010 (1)
- June 2010 (1)
- July 2010 (1)
- August 2010 (1)
- September 2010 (1)
- October 2010 (1)
- November 2010 (1)
- December 2010 (1)
- January 2011 (1)
- February 2011 (1)
- April 2011 (1)
- May 2011 (1)
- July 2011 (1)
- August 2011 (1)
- October 2011 (1)
- November 2011 (1)
- December 2011 (1)
- January 2012 (1)
- February 2012 (1)
- April 2012 (1)
- August 2012 (1)
- September 2012 (1)
- October 2012 (1)
- November 2012 (1)
- December 2012 (1)
- January 2013 (1)
- February 2013 (1)
- April 2013 (1)
- June 2013 (1)
- August 2013 (1)
- October 2013 (1)
- November 2013 (1)
- December 2013 (1)
- January 2014 (1)
- April 2014 (1)
- May 2014 (1)
- Mark O'Keefe (127)
- Alan Levitt (109)
- USDEC Staff (57)
- Tom Suber (41)
- Margaret Speich (22)
- Marc A.H. Beck (15)
- Angélique Hollister (11)
- Vikki Nicholson-West (10)
- Tom Vilsack (8)
- Jaime Castaneda (7)
- Margaret Speich and Mark O'Keefe (7)
- Ross Christieson (7)
- Véronique Lagrange (7)
- Matt McKnight (6)
- Alan Levitt and Marc Beck (5)
- Shawna Morris (4)
- Brad Gehrke (3)
- Kristi Saitama (3)
- Marilyn Hershey (3)
- USDEC Communications (3)
- Luke Waring (2)
- Merle McNeil (2)
- Amy Foor (1)
- Amy Wagner (1)
- Andrei Mikhalevsky (1)
- Annie Bienvenue (1)
- Brad Scott (1)
- Dalilah Ghazalay (1)
- Dermot Carey (1)
- Errico Auricchio (1)
- Jeremy Travis (1)
- Jim Mulhern (1)
- Kara McDonald (1)
- Mitchell Bowling (1)
- Rodrigo Fernandez (1)
- Ross Christieson and Shawna Morris (1)
- Sandra Benson (1)